Nancy Shelley

Nancy Shelley, 73, of Baldwinsville, passed away December 26, 2025. Nancy was born in Brooklyn, New York on April 26, 1952 to James and Anna Neustadt. She moved to the Syracuse area from Brooklyn, NY in 2004.

 In her free time, she enjoyed diamond painting, ceramics, crafts and cooking. She took great pride in raising her family, children and grandchildren. She enjoyed cats and loved playing bingo.

She was preceded in death by her parents; her brother, James Neustadt and sister, Jean Neustadt.

She is survived by her spouse of 34 years, Gary W. Shelley, Three daughters, Annmarie (Ahmed Gahelrasoul) Guadalupe of Brooklyn, Elizabeth (Miguel Ortiz) Guadalupe - Ortiz, Danielle (James) Liddic; son, Joseph Guadalupe; brother, Walter Neustadt; eight grandchildren and two great grandchildren.

Family and friends may call on Wednesday, December 31, 2025  from 12:00pm - 4:30pm at New Comer Cremations & Funerals, 705 N. Main St, North Syracuse. A funeral service will follow at 4:30pm. 

To share a memory of Nancy or leave a special message for her family, visit the guest book below.